A Review of False Note (Alibis Collection, #3)
As a book blogger, I often find myself drawn to stories that explore the complexities of human relationships and the shadows that family can cast over our lives. False Note, the third entry in the Alibis Collection by author David Lagercrantz, intrigued me, especially given his pedigree of continuing Stieg Larsson’s Millennium series. I was curious whether Lagercrantz would channel some of the intense emotional depth found in Larsson’s work. However, what I found left me feeling decidedly out of tune.
In this story, we meet William, the son of a celebrated opera singer in Stockholm, who has spent his life under the dual pressures of his father’s fame and his troubling private behavior. The premise is ripe for exploration—how parental legacies can shape our identities, and how we negotiate love and personal history. Yet, it felt like the symphony that could have been played fell flat, striking all the wrong notes.
While the pacing of the narrative is commendable—easily consumed in a quick sitting of 20-30 minutes—the emotional depth and character development unfortunately stagnate. The characters, while they spark some interest, remain tragically flat. William and his girlfriend, Ebba, are haunted by the specter of his father, yet their interactions lack relatability and growth. It is hard to muster sympathy when there’s little to no self-realization taking place. Rather than creating an emotionally compelling journey, the writing fails to encourage the reader to care about the characters’ fates beyond mere curiosity.
Several themes weave through False Note, including a deep-seated exploration of “daddy issues” and troubled legacies. Lagercrantz’s use of unreliable first-person narration might be intended to create suspense, but for me, it did the opposite—it muddled the story, leaving me frustrated and detached. Something about the portrayal of relationships felt off; a man writing a woman’s experience can sometimes miss the mark, and here, it did just that.
The Swedish setting of Stockholm promised so much, yet it often felt like background scenery instead of an integral part of the storyline. I couldn’t shake the feeling that this story could have been set anywhere. I even found myself overthinking the potential nod to "Stockholm Syndrome," which became a distraction rather than a thematic underpinning.
Despite its issues, it’s worth noting that False Note does wrap up its plot with an unexpected ending, a twist I appreciated. The journey to get there, however, felt muddled and predictable, lacking the suspense or mystery I had hoped for. With only a cast of a few characters, it becomes glaringly obvious who the ‘culprit’ is long before it’s revealed, further contributing to my dissatisfaction.
Ultimately, I can see False Note working as a quick read for those looking for a simple story without heavy emotional baggage. However, for readers seeking depth, complexity, or a memorable journey, this installment in the Alibis series might not hit the right chord. I won’t be returning for a deeper dive into Lagercrantz’s work, as this experience leaves me a bit hesitant. If you’re a fan of straightforward narratives and enjoy stories about familial entanglements, this might still resonate with you, but I’d suggest keeping your expectations tempered.
In the symphony of reader experiences, I can only give False Note a 2-star rating. Here’s hoping the next entry in the Alibis Collection strikes a more harmonious chord. 🎶
Discover more about False Note (Alibis Collection, #3) on GoodReads >>