Review: The Christmas Murder Game by Clara McLoughlin
When I stumbled upon The Christmas Murder Game by Clara McLoughlin, I was immediately drawn in by the promise of a gripping murder mystery set in the English countryside—a perfect cozy read for the holiday season! Who wouldn’t be intrigued by the combination of twists, secrets, and a grand estate? Let’s just say, the experience of diving into this book left me more riled up than ready to unwind with a mug of hot cocoa.
From the outset, the setting of Endgame House emerged as a captivating backdrop. The name alone—Endgame—evokes thoughts of high-stakes drama, much like an Avengers finale. But instead of making my pulse race with excitement, the name had me rolling my eyes—who names a house like that? Surely, I thought, at least the characters would redeem this misstep. Sadly, they proved to be the most unidimensional cast I’ve encountered in a while, each one defined by mere caricatures: spineless Lily, the awful Sara, the protective yet tiresome Tom… you get the picture. Not only were they frustratingly shallow, but their actions—especially Sara’s cringe-worthy cruelty—felt exaggerated and unrealistic. One would think even a passive character like Lily might find her voice when faced with such relentless meanness.
The plot, centered around unsolvable riddles designed to engage the characters, swiftly turned into a tedious exercise in frustration. I found myself longing for the clever intricacies of an Agatha Christie novel—a hope that was dashed into oblivion as I realized the riddles referred to things that simply hadn’t been introduced to us. Instead of clever twists, I was bombarded with Lily’s incessant mourning over her mother, rendering significant chapters tedious and meaningless.
As for the writing style, let’s just say it didn’t do the narrative any favors. McLoughlin’s attempt at metaphors often left me scratching my head rather than feeling emotionally engaged. "Cruelty ran through Liliana like tannic raisins in tea-soaked brack"? What kind of comparison is that? And as for the sheer absurdities—like a woman alone in a maze with a snapped neck being ruled a suicide—I found myself smirking at the sheer silliness of it all rather than engaging with the plot.
While the book struggled with pacing and engagement, I still clung to the hope that it might surprise me with a clever conclusion. Unfortunately, the predictability of the ending only added to my frustration. The two potential suspects—Tom and Sara—felt too obvious to provide any real thrill.
In the world of cozy mysteries, a reader usually seeks clever plotting intertwined with relatable characters and witty dialogue—a blend that The Christmas Murder Game regrettably lacks. While I had high hopes for a seasonal treat, this book will likely thrive more on shelf displays than in the hearts of its readers.
If you’re the type who thrives on the comfort of well-crafted mystery plots, The Christmas Murder Game might leave you defeated rather than enchanted. But, for readers who enjoy a bit of holiday chaos—or those who appreciate good old-fashioned mockery of poor writing—it could provide an entertaining diversion.
In the end, I walked away from this experience shaking my head more than I care to admit. And while my insides boiled with rage over missed opportunities, I feel compelled to share this cautionary tale with fellow readers. Just because a book promises an enticing setup doesn’t mean it delivers—but oh, what a journey to express that frustration!
Discover more about The Christmas Murder Game on GoodReads >>