Every Sweet Thing Is Bitter by Amanda Crewson: A Journey of Healing and Family Dynamics
When I first stumbled upon Every Sweet Thing Is Bitter by Amanda Crewson, I was drawn in by its poignant premise—an exploration of familial ties that bind and unbind us. Fresh out of prison, Providence returns to a home marred by pain, longing to find her missing mother and piece together her fragmented life. I couldn’t help but feel an immediate connection to a character grappling with her past and seeking redemption. After sitting with this complex story for a few hours, I ultimately rated it 4 stars, a choice that reflects both my admiration for Crewson’s writing and my frustration with its slow pacing.
The narrative follows Providence as she navigates a world both familiar and alien, returning home to face the reality of her family’s estrangement. Her sisters, Harmony and Grace, harbor resentment, while her father—still alive and embodying the oppressive weight of abuse—remains an ever-present figure in her life. The rural setting, filled with a haunting small-town atmosphere reminiscent of True Detective, sets the stage for a slow-burning tale of anguish and survival.
What struck me most about Every Sweet Thing Is Bitter was Crewson’s ability to delve deep into her characters’ psyches. Providence, my sweet child, feels both lovable and unlovable—a paradox that tugged at my heartstrings. Her struggle for acceptance and love, compounded by her yearning to reconnect with the mother she lost, resonated powerfully with me. Crewson takes her time to build each character thoughtfully, illustrating their vulnerabilities and pains in a way that compelled me to care deeply about their fates. The family dynamics were so richly depicted that even as I wrestled with feelings of disdain for her estranged family, I couldn’t help but acknowledge that they, too, were products of their history and trauma.
However, I must address the pacing—something that, for the majority of the first half, left me yearning for action. I found myself screaming internally for Providence to start her search for her mother if she truly cared as much as she professed. There were moments when the narrative felt stagnant, which made the waiting almost excruciating. Yet, this slow build is likely intentional, mirroring Providence’s own journey of self-discovery amidst a backdrop of indifference.
The emotional weight of the book is undeniable. Crewson’s exploration of themes like familial loyalty, betrayal, and the search for identity lingered long after I closed the pages. It’s a heavy read, leaving some questions unanswered—but perhaps that’s what makes it so impactful. Life, after all, isn’t neatly packaged with resolutions.
In conclusion, I would recommend Every Sweet Thing Is Bitter to readers who appreciate raw, character-driven stories that reflect the complexities of family ties. It’s perfect for those who embrace slow-burning narratives rich in emotional depth, reminiscent of the tension and ambiguity often found in life itself. Personally, this book forced me to confront my notions of love and forgiveness, and reminded me of the bittersweetness of home. If you’re ready for a journey through the bittersweet complexities of human connection, then this poignant narrative might just find its way into your heart.
Discover more about Every Sweet Thing Is Bitter on GoodReads >>