Review of Finlay Donovan Digs Her Own Grave (Finlay Donovan, #5) by Elle Cosimano
From the moment I cracked open the fifth book in Elle Cosimano’s delightful series, Finlay Donovan Digs Her Own Grave, I was once again swept into the chaotic whirlwind of a world that feels achingly familiar yet utterly outrageous. The blend of humor and mystery continues to hook me—this rollercoaster of a read showcases the complexities of life, love, and motherhood wrapped in a murder mystery, all while remaining highly relatable.
This latest installment finds our protagonist, Finlay Donovan, navigating a fresh personal crisis marked by the presence of a newly exhumed body in her neighbor Mrs. Haggerty’s backyard. Just when one might think that discovering a corpse is the apex of trouble, enter Finlay’s estranged husband, Stephen, who finds himself arrested on suspicion of murder. In typical Finlay fashion, she leaps headfirst into a dilemma that bears not just the weight of her suspicions but also the delicate balance of familial loyalty and societal expectation.
One of the standout themes in this book is the nuanced exploration of familial bonds amidst chaos. Finlay’s internal struggle to defend her ex, the father of her children, speaks volumes about the complexities women often face when their lives intertwine with those of their imperfect partners. I found myself empathizing deeply with Finlay’s predicament; it’s a true reflection of a mom caught between her children’s well-being and the hard truths of adult life. Cosimano masterfully illustrates that motherhood is not just black-and-white—there are shadows of gray lurking everywhere, making Finlay’s choices both relatable and fiercely real.
The pacing of Digs Her Own Grave felt as lively as a conversation over coffee with a friend—breezy yet packed with substance. Cosimano’s ability to weave multiple plot lines without losing the essence of the story is a testament to her skill. The characterization of Mrs. Haggerty took an exciting turn, revealing layers that I never anticipated, which only added zest to an already popping narrative.
However, I found the repeated emphasis on the romances of Finlay and her best friend Vero to be a slight distraction. While I appreciate the representation of love in different forms, the focus on their romantic entanglements sometimes felt a bit heavy-handed. The delightful friendship they share warrants just as much attention as any romantic subplot, and I often wished those moments had prominence instead.
All in all, Finlay Donovan Digs Her Own Grave is a delightful addition to the series that balances the gravity of its themes with the levity of its humor. If you’ve been following Finlay’s escapades from the beginning, you won’t want to miss this latest adventure. And if you haven’t yet been introduced to this captivating world, be prepared for a funny, messy, and heartwarming ride.
I wholeheartedly recommend this book to anyone who relishes mystery wrapped in humor and a dash of reality. It’s the kind of read that not only entertains but makes you think about the struggles and joys of family life—issues that resonate far beyond the pages. I cannot wait to see where Cosimano will take us next in this witty, engaging series!
Discover more about Finlay Donovan Digs Her Own Grave (Finlay Donovan, #5) on GoodReads >>