Book Review: The Enemy’s Daughter by Melissa Poett
From the moment I stumbled upon The Enemy’s Daughter by Melissa Poett, I felt a spark of intrigue. As a devoted fan of fantasy, especially those with rich political layers and character-driven plots, this title had my attention from its teasing premise. So, I dove in, not expecting the delightful surprise it turned out to be.
Set against a backdrop that cleverly intertwines medieval fantasy and dystopian elements, Poett crafts a world that feels at once familiar and refreshing. Initially, it lures you into the typical realm of kingdoms and warfare, only to gradually unveil a deeper narrative. The fascinating concept of a “history looping back” truly captivated me. It’s a rare gem in modern fantasy, offering readers the nostalgia of a lost era while hinting at the remnants of a technologically advanced, yet shattered, past. The world-building grips you from the first page, making it hard to believe I finished the book in less than six hours—the pages practically turned themselves!
At the heart of this narrative are Isadora and Tristan, two characters who instantly pulled me in. Isadora is not your typical overpowered heroine; she’s a well-rounded individual, rich with intelligence and curiosity yet grounded by her compassion. Her journey unfolds as she learns about the intricacies of her world, revealing a character depth that’s too often overlooked in fantasy. And let me tell you, her ability to handle a knife felt not only refreshing but necessary, underscoring her strong, yet grounded presence.
Then there’s Tristan, introduced as the ‘enemy’ in Isadora’s eyes. Initially presented as a brooding figure, I was taken aback by how quickly he transformed into a caring, gentle soul. His moral compass and quietly ambitious nature add layers to his character that many “shadow boys” often lack. This balance—being good-hearted without sacrificing complexity—was a brilliant touch that made me root for him even more.
The political landscape Poett navigates is a rich tapestry, filled with moral ambiguity that kept me guessing throughout. Rather than the conventional “good vs. evil” trope, we’re treated to a narrative full of deception, manipulation, and secrecy, all adding weight to an already high-stakes environment. This complexity not only made the plot more engaging but also heightened the emotional connection to the characters.
And let’s talk about the romance. What a breath of fresh air it was to encounter a YA fantasy that centers on genuine emotional connection rather than physical attraction. Isadora and Tristan’s relationship develops organically, built on mutual respect and real growth. The creativity in using the forced proximity and marriage trope added an electric tension without veering into cliché territory.
However, I did note one small hiccup: the romance’s early pacing felt a bit rushed for me, and the revelation that Tristan had feelings for Isadora from the beginning felt like a missed opportunity for slow-burn tension. Yet, this minor flaw didn’t diminish my overall enjoyment of their heartfelt connection.
As I flipped the last page, I couldn’t help but smile. The Enemy’s Daughter embraced everything I adore about fantasy—complex world-building, adorned with an emotionally resonant romance—while remaining a standalone novel, which is a blessing in today’s series-dominated market.
If you find yourself waning in enthusiasm for adult fantasy heavy on physical desires or YA attempting artificial “maturity,” you should certainly pick up this book. Its beautifully crafted story offers just the emotional depth and intelligent romance many of us have been longing for.
Highly recommend it to anyone who craves:
- Political intrigue and morally gray conflicts,
- Dystopian settings wrapped in medieval charm,
- Empowering yet relatable heroines,
- Emotional, slow-burn romances devoid of spice for the sake of spice.
Thank you, Netgalley, for the ARC! I am definitely looking to add a physical copy to my collection upon release. Happy reading!
Discover more about The Enemy’s Daughter on GoodReads >>