The Fourth Girl (Haven Cliff, #1) – A Journey into Shadows
When I first heard about The Fourth Girl by Wendy Corsi Staub, I couldn’t resist the allure of a mystery woven into the fabric of friendship and dark secrets. Staub, a writer I’ve admired for her Lily Dale Mystery series, has an impressive ability to create tension and atmosphere. The premise of three friends revisiting their haunted past on the anniversary of a disappearance intrigued me. Yet, as I delved into Haven Cliff’s enigmatic world, my excitement softened into a reflective pause.
The story revolves around a decades-old mystery, the haunting disappearance of Caroline Winterfield on prom night. Midge, Kelly, and Talia—the surviving trio—reunite at the site of their friend’s last known whereabouts, only to find themselves drawn into a chilling investigation after a body is discovered. The themes of friendship, betrayal, and the haunting impact of unresolved trauma are certainly compelling, and I expected the delicate balance of nostalgia and horror to unravel effortlessly. However, the execution fell short of that promise.
The characters, unfortunately, felt more like shadows than the vibrant individuals I hoped for. Midge, the police detective, is laden with a sense of responsibility, yet I didn’t feel a strong desire to cheer for her or her friends. Their struggles seemed repetitive and lacked the depth needed for me to truly connect. Kelly and Talia oscillated between courage and fear, but I couldn’t quite grasp their motivations, which left me feeling disengaged from their journey.
One of the most confusing aspects of The Fourth Girl was the narrative style. The constant shifting between timelines and viewpoints led to moments of frustration, as I found myself sorting through tangled threads rather than enjoying a seamless flow of suspense. The writing, while at times poetic, fell prey to excessive exposition that dulled the tension. I anticipated a gripping plot filled with suspense—a hallmark of thrillers—but instead, found myself trudging through a landscape where little happened. As much as I tried to tap into the potential of this story, it often felt as though the elements were stuck in neutral.
The moment that stood out for me in the excerpt I shared—a clearing in the woods, a skeleton, and the echoes of what was once a vibrant friendship—did hold a tantalizing promise of mystery. However, the execution of such poignant imagery felt underwhelming by the time I reached the conclusion. Too often, I felt like I was hovering above the surface without diving deep into the waters of emotional intensity and suspense.
Despite my mixed feelings, I do believe this book will resonate with readers who enjoy a slower-paced mystery. Fans of character-driven narratives that favor atmosphere over action may find solace in Staub’s storytelling. However, if you’re looking for a tightly woven thriller that keeps you on the edge of your seat, you might want to look elsewhere.
In reflecting on my journey through The Fourth Girl, I’m reminded that not every read can soar to breathtaking heights. Sometimes, even an author I admire can create a book that doesn’t quite resonate with me. While I may not be continuing with the Haven Cliff series, the experience has reinforced my appreciation for the complexities of storytelling and the myriad paths authors take in exploring the human experience. Readers, I encourage you to pick it up and discover your own truth within the pages.
Discover more about The Fourth Girl (Haven Cliff, #1) on GoodReads >>