The Maid’s Secret: A Bittersweet Farewell to Molly’s World
When I first picked up The Maid by Kathleen M. Smith, I never imagined that I would become so invested in the quirky charm of Molly the Maid and her beautiful escapades at the Regency Grand. As I delved into The Maid’s Secret, the grand finale of the beloved series, there was a part of me filled with hope—and a touch of trepidation. Would this final act live up to the standards set by its predecessors, or would it fall short? Unfortunately, it seems the latter crept into the pages more than I would have liked.
In this fourth installment, we find our beloved Molly, now Head Maid and Special Events Manager, on the brink of marriage to Juan Manuel. The excitement peaks when a reality TV crew descends on the Regency Grand, bringing with them the anticipation of treasures—and, of course, secrets. However, as the story unfolds, it becomes evident that the true gem isn’t Molly’s own narrative, but rather the backstory of her Gran, Flora. This is where the plot begins to shift, taking a direction that both intrigued and frustrated me.
On one hand, I was glad to dive into Flora’s world, and the diary format initially captivated me. However, as the narrative progressed, the diary lost its authenticity. Instead of a series of intimate confessions, it transformed into a conventional narrative, straying from the deeply personal touch that makes diary entries so special. Additionally, while some revelations in Flora’s past were engaging, they often felt predictably straightforward. With Flora’s fate already established in the previous books, there was little suspense to be found, which was a letdown for someone like me who craves that edge-of-the-seat tension.
Molly, on the other hand, consistently brings that spark. Though her perspective is granted less space than it deserved in this volume, her character is as relatable as ever—infused with her trademark “Molly-isms.” I chuckled at her attempts to incorporate modern lingo from Speedy, the quirky new recruit, showing how far she has come while still navigating the funny, awkward waters of language.
This isn’t to say The Maid’s Secret lacks charm. The moments with old favorites, like Angela, were heartwarming and lent a sense of continuity that felt good. Plus, the premise of a theft, while not the nail-biter one might hope for, kept things interesting enough. But the climax was rather lackluster, and not in a way that leaves you thinking about the implications long after you close the book.
In conclusion, I would recommend The Maid’s Secret primarily to those who have journeyed with Molly and Flora throughout the series. While it’s more about resolution than mystery, and while the exploration of Flora’s past may not tick all the boxes, it still gives loyal fans a peek into Molly’s happily ever after. This installment may not soar as high as its predecessors, but it provides a warm, if somewhat predictable, ending to a series filled with charms, quirks, and life’s little lessons. I’m content with how it wrapped up Molly’s arc, but I can’t help wishing it had delivered more excitement and depth, particularly in the mystery department.
For what it’s worth, I take away a fond nostalgia as I close this chapter on Molly’s adventures—a series that truly showcased the importance of connection, legacy, and that life is often a delightful mess. Here’s to the memories, and this cozy world that captured my heart.
Rating: 3 stars (mostly for Molly’s story).
Thank you to HarperCollins UK and HarperFiction for the advance reader copy of "The Maid’s Secret." This review reflects my honest opinion.
Discover more about The Maid’s Secret (Molly the Maid, #3) on GoodReads >>