Review: Throne of Glass by Sarah J. Maas
When I first picked up Throne of Glass, I was immediately drawn in by its thrilling premise: a notorious assassin given a shot at freedom through a lethal tournament against the land’s best criminals. As I cracked open the book and delved into Sarah J. Maas’s world, excitement surged through me—until it didn’t. What transpired instead was a frustrating journey steeped in missed potential, and I felt like I was riding a roller coaster that plummeted from its peak far too soon.
The story follows Celaena Sardothien, an exceptional assassin who finds herself enslaved in the salt mines. The stakes couldn’t be higher; here is a young woman with the skills to kill, someone who earns her freedom through a competition that promises bloodshed. At first, Celaena’s character excited me—she’s fierce, she’s sharp-tongued, and she should, in theory, embody the badassery we all crave. Yet, with every chapter, I found myself questioning her motivations amidst a whirlwind of melodrama that felt more pink fairy tale than brutal survival.
The pacing took a hit, too. I expected nail-biting competition sequences filled with fierce rivalry; instead, I ended up with more scenes of Celaena in lavish rooms, obsessing over clothing and the prince’s affections, than actual blood and bone clashes. What was once a gripping setup about an assassin gradually draped itself in Cinderella-like flounces, leaving me baffled. “Where is the grit?” I kept asking as she fretted over fashion and flirted rather than flayed her opponents.
Mas’s writing style brings a whimsical charm to the prose, but this magic often veered into the realm of too much fluff, overshadowing the critical tension designed to grip the reader. For instance, interactions brimming with sarcasm and wit were frequent, yet they sometimes detracted from the potential darkness of the narrative. When Celaena is more concerned about a puppy’s behavior than honing her assassin skills, I groaned. The frequent meandering musings often made me feel like a reader lost in the wrong fairytale.
Despite my critiques, there were moments that sparked intrigue. The hints of impending danger such as the mysterious deaths of competitors carried a shadow that was exciting. However, they did little to rescue a narrative that too often focused on Celaena’s delightful little distractions. I liked her spirit but wished for more depth; a ferocious fighter shouldn’t be consumed by the woes of romance. “For the world’s greatest assassin, this is pathetic,” Dorian remarks, and I couldn’t help but agree.
In all fairness, Throne of Glass might appeal to readers seeking a lighter, romantic fantasy with a fierce female lead—particularly those who enjoy fairy tale retellings that integrate familiar elements with new twists. That said, for someone looking for a raw, emotionally driven narrative or a deep dive into the mechanics of competition and survival, look elsewhere. Books like Graceling or Poison Study might be more aligned with what you’re hunting for.
As I turned the final page, I had to reflect: while Throne of Glass had the potential to be an invigorating tale of grit and glory, it often leaned toward soft-focus distractions instead. Though I could see how it might enchant some readers, I couldn’t shake the feeling of a dazzling glass castle: beautiful from a distance, but lacking substance upon closer inspection.
Discover more about Throne of Glass (Throne of Glass, #1) on GoodReads >>